Review by PT32

Posted:
14 Sep 2008, 04:52
For: Sultans GunPalace
Level rating: 7.9
Rating
8.1

Yeah, I’d have to agree with cooba there, it’s not all it’s mocked up to be…

Quality was allright, in that it was a decently playable ctf level, but while playability wasn’t the issue, eyecandy was…
My eyes were severly abused by your eyecandy. It wasn’t innately bad, in that it wasn’t inappropriate, but you used it [the eye candy] very poorly, lashing the user with too many bright colors and useless junk. Definitely some work needed.
Music did not fit with the level at all, it should’ve had an Arabian feel to it, not this “new discovery” idea.
Like cooba said, the level is structured with baselike concepts, which would take a while to get down pat. What’s with the off-limits areas? That’s just stupid. Could you maybe just not have put them there at all? But, I will comment on how good the concept was, on how funny the scrolls were [Kill the chickens! KILL THE CHICKENS!!!], on how well overtly structured the level was, so there were positive things here.
To sum up, I think you could’ve done better. You are very skilled at this, it’s just not the best it could be. I’m tempted to say I understand how you feel, but I say that to everyone so it gets old fast. Just keep a’hacking away at it, and it’ll be even better then before!
Readers, you decide if you want to download. It’s a good level, but the bad factors cancel out the good.

RecommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
14 Sep 2008, 04:34
For: JJ1Turtemple
Level rating: 8.9
Rating
8.8

Well, here we have a pretty good conversion! Now, before you go and spit hate all over my review, let me hasten to add that there were some mistakes in the set. But, let us talk of good first.

GOOD THINGS
The warping bg, despite what Violet seems to think, is a very good idea. Every tileset designer has a trademark that they leave in their conversions, and the warping background is NOKA’s. It is excecuted very well. Having four different versions of the tileset is a definite pro, even if they aren’t really that much different from each other. Music was JJ1, which is nice, not having to scout all over to find it. But, now for the
BAD THINGS
The very first thing I want to point out is a very serious bug, that NONE of the other reviewers on this entire page caught. This is the half-height floor tile in the red curtain. It bounces up and down during the animation sequence, a consequence of poorly done pasting on NOKA’s part. I agree with Violet about poles and stuff like that, and the text from Jazz1 [I was disappointed to not find it there, you can’t hardly read it at all in the conversion], and the sucker tubes…I’m tempted to say they suck, but as that is so extremely corny, I wont. They should’ve maybe had some backing on them, which disappointed me. Or at least another version WITH a back.
So, to all you who are reading, I will recommend this to dl, but understand that NOKA could easily make improvement on it, if he wanted to. Just keep at it!

Not recommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
14 Sep 2008, 04:04
For: Sand Ocean
Level rating: 6.3
Rating
4.9

Well, it needs work. That was the first thing that crossed my mind. Allow me to explain…
The quality was…Average. Gameplay was all right, items and enemies were ok, but some of the baddies were stuck in 2-tile ruts, which seemed very annoying. There were a lot of places where I got lost and had to use the editor [which is never good], only to find the path was a 1-tile gap, or not even in that area, or hinging on 1 little coin I missed somewhere in the level. Not very good! The boss at the end didn’t work properly, it clashed with the set [in my opinion, Bubba doesn’t fit with the Beach tileset], and vanished almost right away! The thorns at the end didn’t work, try moving them up one row. Tiles were mediocre. Still, you could’ve used one of the more interesting versions of the Beach tileset, instead of the standard one. Same with the music, too. A little creativity goes a long way.There were bugs, bugs bugs everywhere! good grief, did you even have a beta tester?! There were logs the I got stuck in scattered everywhere, the baddies tended to get stuck, the boss and his thorns didn’t work, you need to fix this. I didn’t like the eye candy that much, either. Once again, you used the standard stuff. :( You could’ve at least invented your own style, instead of copying the base version. Did you do anything with the set that the Epic folks didn’t It’s hard to tell. At least you included some. But make your own, please!

And now, a bright spot at last! Works in TSF, and 1.23, at least there’s that good news. Thank goodness. However, the readme didn’t make much sense to me, about connecting level 1 with level 2, until I read the tiny hald-sentence at the end:
“If you didn’t download so-and-so, oh well”. At least, that’s the gist of it. Frustrating, because you could have easily included the other level, instead of forcing me to have to find the other one. Not appreciated!

To sum it all up, I think that you gotta go back and fix this level. Immediately. A little creativity may go a long way, but there was little to speak of here. I beg you to go back and fix it, for the dl’ers’ sakes. Readers, I would not recommend downloading this, unless you want a singleplayer level in slight need of work (I am not insulting Wazz, I just don’t enjoy this level). Wait for him to fix it up a bit.

RecommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
14 Sep 2008, 03:50 (edited 22 May 10, 16:16)
For: CrysilisV
Level rating: 9.7
Rating
9.5

Ok ok, this’ll be the featured one. I hope. Anyway…
DESIGN
Good job, good job. You put in lots of different styles [I like how you put tiles from Stonar and other places into the set], and made it interesting. However, the brown rocks are supposed to be a background, not solid tiles. How do I know? Well, the nature of the secret project I am working on reveals just that. Oh well, that’s what an updated version is for.
EYE CANDY
Lots of it, you again kept the tileset interesting. The water on the bridges, the vultures, the egg[s], it’s all well thought out. Kudos!
USEFULNESS
Well, that’s where I’d wobble a bit. See, it’s such an amazing incredible set, but I think it needs a little work in that area. Esp that black rock background. I dunno. I’m feeling generous, so I’ll give you a good rating.
SUMMARY:
Overall, you did [another] phenomenal job, wowing me again, and I look forward to your next edition. Download this, and have fun!
[By the way, could someone please make a “good” TechNoir set? Just asking] Regards!

NOTE TO READERS: please don’t say this review is helpful. I totally recognise what bantha fodder it really is. :P

RecommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
14 Sep 2008, 03:39
For: Troglobite's Dark Forest Adventure
Level rating: 7.5
Rating
7.6

All right, judging by the amount of criticism I received for this, I decided to examine this pack a bit more closely. I discovered that it really wasn’t so bad after all, had a fairly creative plotline [Devan swipes Eva, you go save her, while the bad guy sneaks in the back and steals your home. So BEWARE OF THE MORTGAGE AGENT! gets slapped on cheek], but music and eyecandy were problems. Not much variety in the designs, music lacked, but now for some positive feedback. At the risk of sounding either like a copycat or a busted record, the level had some very interesting gameplay, with plenty of playing involved instead of sitting on your hands. Plenty of spread out levels [though not so spread out that you wasted time going back and forth], the plot was excellent, so this pack does quite better than I originally thought. I will give you around what everybody else gave you, which will be a 7.6, and a definite download recommendation!

Review by PT32

Posted:
12 Sep 2008, 21:06
For: [DOM] Lost Onyx
Level rating: 7.4
Rating
7.9

Well, this is a pretty good level. Not the best I’ve ever seen, but good anyway. Lots of layered walls in the bg, a border around the scren in lyr 1, okay weapon placement, this has the markings of a map for a 5-minute game. This is because of its small size, and its humdrum eyecandy [too little too far spread]. If you could go and fix the details up a bit, that’d be excellent. Increase the size a bit, touch up here and there, and this level will be great! I leave it to the reader to decide on whether or not to dl this.

RecommendedReview by DAEMON

Posted:
12 Sep 2008, 11:56 (edited 28 Sep 08, 18:52)
For: jp-->4-1 Turtemple
Level rating: 9.3
Rating
9.2

Nice work. But they are in him smaller errors :(
ERORRS: according to me too much in him the weapon and too much the enemy there is a part on the second level where the air board disappears and may not be to get out of the church :(
But these disregarding whole good :)
Please repair it… (Rating:6.2)
———————————————————-
hmm… Not everybody an exception or this repair his spoiled level but good :) Nah was whole good one now :) But according to me yet always a lot in him the weapon but at least it you repaired the other mistake… now very good:) (Rating:9.2)

RecommendedQuick Review by FireSworD

Posted:
12 Sep 2008, 11:39 (edited 12 Sep 08, 11:48)
For: Device
Level rating: 8.6
Rating
8.2

Snooze and DS did it. The level looks nice and plays just as good. However it’s not anything really special (thus the rather undiscriptive review). It’s just a good battle level for events and public servers.

RecommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
12 Sep 2008, 00:46
For: Jazz 1: Sluggion
Level rating: 8.1
Rating
9.8

Sigh… A jazz1 conversion. How many of those we’ve seen….
But, it’s certainly a good one! As the title suggests, this is a conversion of the Jazz1 planet Sluggion. Correct bg, palette is deadon, fair amount of sluff tiles [tiles that serve no purpose, except to look cool], this is a very good conversion! My one beef is that it is a bit small. But this is not a big beef. Back to the set. It will be infinitely useful to anybody converting Jazz1 levels (whop unngh..), making battles, ctf, or basically whatever you happen to think of. DL. It’s sweet.

RecommendedReview by DAEMON

Posted:
11 Sep 2008, 05:41
For: BBB
Level rating: 6.7
Rating
6.7

beautiful work not bad but was a little bit short according to me na all the same… then mistakes: BOSS was a mistake for me on an level but I do not know it that you are for me for everybody only??? bugs I did not take it to reason in him from the greatest part of the music matches the tilesetben they were smaller mistakes… and yet something: you do not want continuation???

Not recommendedReview by FawFul

Posted:
10 Sep 2008, 15:34 (edited 10 Sep 08, 15:38 by FawFulcc)
For: jp-->3-1 Fanolint
Level rating: 3.1
Rating
2

no offense, but lately this irritates me as hell.
you can figure out what i mean.
wavs don’t run in jj2, and just don’t give higher ratings for musics.
level is not very fun. actually a whole copy. i don’t get the point, if i want to play this is will play jj1 instead.
i don’t see myself playing this, since i don’t get the point why i should.

Review by XÐxP

Posted:
10 Sep 2008, 15:17 (edited 10 Sep 08, 15:27 by cooba)
For: Toxic Tower
Level rating: 7.4
Rating
N/A

cool lvl ;)

[Rating (4.2) clearance. – cooba]

RecommendedQuick Review by DAEMON

Posted:
10 Sep 2008, 14:25
For: [NC] Water in Submarine
Level rating: 6.1
Rating
7.7

hmmm… This level was very good for me very much likes mainly it you took advantage of the single parts of the tileset fantastic… But could be you should try to make single Single Player level of him according to me. Donot you think??? OKAY?

RecommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
9 Sep 2008, 20:29
For: Hallows Eve
Level rating: 8.2
Rating
8.9

Okay, Faw, your level’s not bad. Pretty good, actually. Eyecandy was excellent, music fit very well, and tileset was maximized in terms of performance. I think I’m actually gonna hafta give you an 8.9! Because I didn’t really see any foreground eyecandy, and this bothered me, and the intro part might cause impatient people to leave the server [their loss :(]. But I can comfortably say that this is a good level, keep it up, and a definite download recommendation.

Not recommendedReview by PT32

Posted:
9 Sep 2008, 20:27
For: My first online pack
Level rating: 5.4
Rating
6.5

Allrighty, let’s review you level…
Overall, good quality, good use of the tileset, but the level flat out stank. I mean, why put the exit right at the beginning? It makes it way too easy, and I didn’t even know what had happened once I went in the bunker. Music was OK, fit the overall feeling well. Eyecandy would’ve been appreciated, though. Still, the level lacks one of the key components of levelmaking today: Usefulness. I got stuck very closely after the start, and this angered me.
So, to finish up the review, let me say good try, but lots of work needed. 6.5, and no dl recommendation.

Quick Review by Jazz funny

Posted:
9 Sep 2008, 17:48 (edited 9 Sep 08, 20:27 by cooba)
For: Tomb Rabbit 2 Unfinished
Level rating: 9.4
Rating
10

Cooooool!!!

[Review changed to quick review. – cooba]

Review by PT32

Posted:
8 Sep 2008, 19:29
For: jp-->3-3 Mega Air Base
Level rating: 9
Rating
N/A

As always, Olo, your feedback is GREATLY appreciated!

As for the levels, don’t worry. I’ll just start making, and I’ll turn it back over to you whenever you get back. Don’t worry a bit. Good luck in life!

RecommendedReview by OLOELO

Posted:
8 Sep 2008, 16:01 (edited 8 Sep 08, 16:01)
For: jp-->3-3 Mega Air Base
Level rating: 9
Rating
9

PT32 this is my last comment when I leave for some time this page.
The levels was very good. Next hard working on this level,if someone wants to play old JJ1 orginal levels,PT32’s are the best.
PT32 unfortunatelly I can’t send my levels to you,because jumps freak error. If you want to submit Episode 3,you must create your own Fanolint and Megairbase levels :)
My rate about this level is…umm..
9.0
I will be back,surely!!! And I’ll return with(maybe)Episode Four ;)

RecommendedReview by Wolfiend

Posted:
8 Sep 2008, 12:06
For: Mario World tileset
Level rating: 7.2
Rating
7.5

To begin this tileset is a weary good job! I Love it! I am happy to review such a promising tileset! Excelent job!

QUALITY
This is good what done in it so far but needs a lot more stuff, so it can be used for a long single player. Its rare to see such a well made Mario tileset, usually they are bad. I tell you to keep working on it!
TILES
Nice the blocks and characters are big as they should be and this makes them easy to use. I love that you put in some character tiles people usually put in a few. You should put in more too. The tiles are made pretty well, just extend it with a lot more.
BUGGYNES
I didn’t find any, but this isn’t say that it can’t have any! Always look for bugs multiple times!
EYE CANDY
I am experienced with eye candy in Mario tilesets and I say it haves just enough what a mario tileset needs. But there is no to much in eye candy so just put in much as you can.
PROBLEMS
Its just to short need more stuffs! A lot more stuffs!

FINAL NOTES

More and more stuff in it! Put in much as you can! You do it really great so continue working on it promise me this!

SCORE:7.0
BONUS SCORES:
EASY USE-0.2
FUNNY BURNED UP MARIO TILE-0.1
MAKING COMPATIBLE FOR 1.23 TOO-0.2

TOTAL SCORE:7.5!!!!

Review by DennisKainz

Posted:
8 Sep 2008, 08:59
For: Castle Filled With Weirdness
Level rating: 3.6
Rating
N/A

Keep on working on your creativity, friend. Maybe someday you will make a great episode.

  1. 1
  2. 266
  3. 267
  4. 268
  5. 269
  6. 270
  7. 271
  8. 272
  9. 273
  10. 274
  11. 1306