Review Exchange
 

I've created this thread in the spirit of encouraging people to write reviews on j2o. The way this thread works is as follows.

1. You post a link to an upload which you want people to review.
2. Someone quotes your post, and agrees to write a review. In their reply they also provide a link to an upload they want reviewed.
3. You quote their post as a confirmation. Both of you proceed to review each others uploads.

You don't have to follow these guidelines EXACTLY, but the way I have outlined them is a good example of how to use this thread. The point is for people to use this thread as a means to agree to trade reviews: "I'll review your level if you review mine." This is something that has been practiced for a very long time. This thread is just a way to facilitate that by providing a neat and organized place for that sort of discussion.


Now for a few rules.

People who fail to reciprocate (as in, they come to an agreement in this thread, receive a review, and yet do not write a review back) will be added to a "list of shame" which will be edited into this post for everyone to see. People on this list will not be allowed to participate in this thread. You can remove yourself from the list if you finally decide to write your review. Repeat offenders may receive more severe punishment.

Stay on topic. This thread is for exchanging reviews, and posts which deviate from that will probably be deleted. In other words, don't post here if you aren't directly participating.

No drama in this thread. If someone hasn't written you a review, send me a private message and I'll add their name to the list. Don't use this thread for calling people out and starting petty arguements.

And one final recommendation: if you want to grab attention, don't just post a link to your upload. Post a screenshot too, and maybe a general description. You don't have to do this, but it's a lot more interesting.

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4500

This still needs a review which doesn't get a rating removal :(

Nice idea Evilmike ;)

These need a fair rating:
"Rayman1 - Forest" - Tileset conversion: http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4687
"Foreign Country" - Battle-lvl built with the abovementioned tileset: http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4688

Screens:
[IMG]http://getpic.info/thumbs/110_11318_screen1.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://getpic.info/thumbs/110_11319_screen2.jpg[/IMG] [IMG]http://getpic.info/thumbs/110_11320_screen3.jpg[/IMG]


Please note that I won't review CTF-levels as I almost never have played ctf (though I like it)

Extraterrestrials

Could use a more detailed review. I will give a detailed review back.

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4681

Plz rate.

or, how about you and gry make an exchange out of your uploads now?

i'm hoping this thread won't turn into a second thread where you only post links to your uploads

I will review this very detaily by tomorrow night. In return I ask for a review of this.

Sure!

How about you take Toxin Twister?

Expect it done by tomorrow night!

Okay.:-)

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4559

I feel like giving a review so I might as well make use of this thread ;P. Expect a typical review of mine in return for whoever reviews that.

What should I review in return?

Everything is up to you. If you're still confused, read the first post again. It's not complicated.

o K i will review this but tomorrow
in return i'd like you to review More Random Battle Levels
(could you kindly be the first one to make the review? thanks)

Expect it to be done by today or tomorrow.

EDIT: Done! ;)

I want that somebody rate this.
I will give a review as soon as possible.

Battle From Freedom

[Battle From Freedom]

Ok. I'll review it. In exchange I want you to review my Jazz secret levels.

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4681

Update: Did the review. Hope you like it!

Ok, I will give a review for that :)

Edit: Did the review!

I'm still looking for more reviews to my level pack, "The Battle for Carrotus".

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4640

I am willing to review pretty much anything in return. And if multiple people decide to review this, I'll be writing multiple reviews too.

Thanks Triple J. And I am doing another project. I'm making secret levels for every theme in the official levels. (Except for the ones that already have them.) Now all I need to know is how to hack Jazz2.exe and I'm set for live!

My hotel of the century!!!
 

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4452

It's a hotel level made by me.

Full of stuff like a store, games to win cash, gambling, free activities, and

*drumroll*

A CUSTOMIZABLE ROOM LIKE NEVER SEEN BEFORE!!!

And a battle room, and a hospital to recover, and a lobby of coarse, and a diner, and a shooting free chatroom with a platform to play on, and...

I think that's about it. I'll have to check.

DOWNLOAD IT NOW!!!

I am not sure that a hotel can qualify as an upload.

What?!
 

Name one reason why it can't. :mad:

Why, it can.

If a person doesn't seem to be reviewing back to your request like he/she has vowed, you could just threat to remove your review from the upload you have reviewed. Or if your review was very detailed and you don't want to get the feeling you wrote it in vain, just remove the rating until this person reviews back.

Done. ;)

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4259

It's a battle/CTF level by me. Based on desert trench warfare. Also called that, heh. Needs a LOT of people to enjoy though! Even ten is too few.

I'm talking a HUGE arena. Enjoy. :-)

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4642

I will try and review back ASAP.

I'd like to state that I will not review music, conversions from games I haven't played, Hotels/Tests, or any uploads in TSF.

I still wanted to review that level, so this is a good reason :)

And a 'typical review of mine in return' sounds good enough to let you review this, I guess: http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4724 ;P

EvilMike!

If I review Battle For Carrotus

(Which is totally awesome, by the way. Love the mission briefing stuff and all)

Will you review either my Desert Trench Warfare or Middlemore Hotel?


I'll get started on my review as soon as you reply.

Sure, could you post a link to those uploads? I will do the review sometime this weekend, whenever I have time.

Edit: finally did it. Sorry for taking so long!

The links for them are above.

Somewhere. :rolleyes:


I'll be able to review your level this evening.

Urban Nightmare of Confusion
I will review anything in exchange of this.

I'll review that if you review the above levels I asked for.

http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...hp?levelID=146

I'll review just about anything except music. Oh, and I would like to see a review of that with 2007 standards.

I'd also like to see a modern review of this

I would like someone to make a nice review of This. In return I can offer a review of pretty much anything that isn't TSF, and isn't music.

Assassination is cool.

I'll review that if you review this:
http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4640

sorry for that i didnt review yet.My internet was fully broken up!!expect this done this today.

Okay, I'll get right on it, but I want you to review mine:
http://www.jazz2online.com/J2Ov2/dow...p?levelID=4737